Thread:Bibimbap0920/@comment-5916265-20130628124022/@comment-9505008-20130628154445

Your title makes no sense lol

The problem with Lilith is that her efficiency is too low. The general trend with vp is that the lower your spirit cost, the more vp you gain. The only scenario where this trend is broken is when the substitutee's efficiency is at least twice that of substituted's. This is the reason why Kotetsu (2040+22%) was used instead of Kaede (900) back when AS restriction didn't exist.

Having said that though, Lilith's substitition might not be too bad - after crunching some numbers, here are the result:

Lilith Lead + 4 Max WW

Avg Attack: 17177.17

Efficiency: 477.14

Max WW Lead + Lilith + 3 Max WW

Avg Attack: 17364.67

Efficiency: 482.35

Max WW Lead + 4 Max WW

Avg Attack: 14247

Efficiency: 474.9

As you can see, Lilith' addition increases the overall efficiency, which theoretically should increase the amount of vp. However, since the relationship between vp and attack has not been definitively defined, I cannot conclusively say that you will earn more vp. I personally think you'll lose 1 or 2 vps, but it shouldn't matter in grand scheme of things. Your choice, really.